mdlifeins.com
Same Portfolio. Same Returns. Two Very Different Retirements. Here's Why

Home  ›  Blog

Same Portfolio. Same Returns. Two Very Different Retirements. Here’s Why

By Dan Walsh · Independent Insurance Broker · NPN 3028543 · Certified Long-Term Care Specialist · Life Insurance & Annuities

mdlifeins.com

Have Dan Contact Me

Life insurance, long-term care, annuities or final expense. Independent broker, multiple carriers, no pressure.

Prefer a quick quiz? LTC · Annuity · Term life

Search

Popular Topics

About the Author

Dan Walsh - Licensed Insurance Agent
Daniel Walsh
NPN 3028543
Independent Broker

I'm Dan Walsh, an independent insurance broker in Brookeville, MD. I specialize in long-term care insurance, fixed indexed annuities, and retirement income planning for families in Maryland and beyond.

I use a "manufacturing approach" to break complex insurance products into clear, understandable components, so you can make confident decisions without pressure. I also have deep expertise in federal benefit planning (FERS/CSRS, WEP/GPO) and IRA/tax strategies.

Before insurance, I founded and ran businesses including Guardian Funding Inc. and Lightning Wear Apparel. I'm licensed in Maryland and multiple other states. Verify my current licenses on NIPR (NPN 3028543). Not sure about your state? Contact me and I'll confirm.

🏅 Fixed Index Annuities 🛡️ Long-Term Care 🎓 Certified Long-Term Care Specialist 📊 Retirement Income
About MD Life Insurance →
🎙️

Protect What You've Built

New episodes weekly — annuity strategy and retirement planning, straight talk only.

Listen Now →

Follow Us

Same Portfolio. Same Returns. Two Very Different Retirements. Here's Why






Same Portfolio. Same Returns. Two Very Different Retirements. Here’s Why. | MD Life Insurance




📋 THE RETIREMENT RISK NOBODY TALKS ABOUT

Same Portfolio. Same Returns. Two Very Different Retirements.

Two clients can start retirement with the same portfolio, take the same withdrawals, and experience the same average annual return — yet have dramatically different outcomes based solely on when positive and negative returns occur. That’s sequence-of-returns risk.

Imagine two retirees. We will call them Tom and Jerry.

Both retire at 65 with $500,000. Both take $25,000 per year to supplement their Social Security. Both invest in the same balanced portfolio. Over the next 20 years, both portfolios experience the exact same average annual return.

But Tom retires into a market downturn. Jerry retires into a bull market.

Twenty years later, Jerry has a healthy portfolio and a comfortable retirement. Tom is running out of money. Same portfolio. Same withdrawals. Same average returns. Dramatically different outcomes.

This is sequence-of-returns risk. And it is the single most under-discussed threat to a successful retirement.

The core insight: When you are accumulating wealth, the order of returns does not matter. When you are withdrawing from that wealth, it matters more than almost anything else.

THE MATH

Why the Order of Returns Matters

This is not a theoretical concern. It is a mathematical certainty. Here is what the numbers actually look like.

Most investors focus on one number: average annual return. They believe that if they get the average right, retirement will work out.

But for anyone withdrawing income from a portfolio, average returns are only part of the story. The sequence — the order in which those returns arrive — is what determines whether the portfolio survives.

📉 The Negative-Returns-First Scenario

You retire with $500,000. You withdraw $30,000 per year. In year one, the market drops 30%. Your portfolio falls to $350,000. You withdraw $30,000, leaving $320,000. In year two, the market recovers 30%. Your portfolio grows to $416,000. You withdraw $30,000. You now have $386,000. Even after a full recovery, you are $114,000 below where you started.

📈 The Positive-Returns-First Scenario

You retire with $500,000. You withdraw $30,000 per year. In year one, the market gains 30%. Your portfolio grows to $650,000. You withdraw $30,000, leaving $620,000. In year two, the market drops 30%. Your portfolio falls to $434,000. You withdraw $30,000. You now have $404,000. You are down, but you are $18,000 ahead of the other sequence.

$18,000
The difference in outcomes after just two years — from the same returns in a different order

Over a 30-year retirement, that gap widens exponentially. Research by Wade Pfau has quantified this effect: the compounded return in the first ten years of retirement accounts for about 77% of the final retirement outcome.

In other words, the first decade of retirement matters more than the next twenty years combined. And if that first decade goes poorly — if you retire into a bear market, a recession, or a prolonged period of low returns — the damage may be permanent.

⚠️ This is not an argument for market timing. Nobody can predict when the next downturn will happen. This is an argument for structural planning — making sure a bad sequence of returns cannot permanently damage your retirement plan.

THE RETIREMENT RED ZONE

The 5 Years Before and After Retirement

This is the period when sequence-of-returns risk is most dangerous. And it is the period most retirees are least prepared for.

Researchers call the five years before and five years after retirement the retirement red zone. This is when a bad sequence of returns can do the most damage — and when most retirees are most vulnerable.

Why? Because this is when you transition from accumulating to withdrawing. And that transition changes everything about how market volatility affects your portfolio.

✅ During Accumulation

  • You are adding money to the portfolio
  • Market downturns are opportunities to buy more shares
  • Volatility works in your favor
  • Time is on your side

❌ During Withdrawal

  • You are taking money out of the portfolio
  • Market downturns force you to sell shares at low prices
  • Volatility works against you
  • Those shares cannot participate in the recovery

The red zone matters because: A 30% market drop the year before you retire is a temporary setback. A 30% drop the year after you retire can be permanent damage.

THE SOLUTION

How to Neutralize Sequence-of-Returns Risk

You cannot control the sequence of returns. You can control how much of your retirement depends on them.

1. Build a Guaranteed Income Floor

The most effective protection against sequence risk is to cover your essential expenses with income that is not tied to the market. Social Security, pension income, and a well-structured annuity create a floor that pays regardless of what the market is doing. When a crash hits in year two of retirement, you do not need to sell anything — because your bills are already covered. This is the foundational principle behind every solid retirement income plan.

2. Maintain a Cash Buffer

Keeping 12 to 24 months of living expenses in cash or short-term fixed instruments means that even if the market crashes the day after you retire, you have runway. You draw from the cash bucket while the portfolio recovers, then replenish when conditions improve. This simple structural separation prevents the forced selling that makes sequence risk so devastating.

3. Delay Social Security

Every year you delay Social Security beyond full retirement age, your benefit grows by approximately 8%. By delaying to 70, you build the largest possible guaranteed, inflation-adjusted income stream. A larger Social Security benefit means a smaller required portfolio withdrawal in any given year — which means less forced selling in a down market. Delaying Social Security is, quite literally, the most cost-effective sequence-risk hedge available to most Americans.

4. Use the Bucket Strategy

Separate your money into three buckets: short-term income needs, medium-term growth, and long-term growth. When the market drops, you fund your lifestyle from the safe bucket — not the growth bucket. This gives the growth bucket time to recover, and it means you never sell a long-term asset at the worst possible moment. For a deeper dive, see our post on the Retirement Income Bucket Strategy.

5. Plan Roth Conversions During the Low-Income Years

The years between retirement and age 73 are the most valuable tax-planning years of your life. Converting Traditional IRA dollars to Roth during this window reduces future RMDs and gives you a tax-free source of income you can tap in a down market without triggering a taxable event. This gives you optionality precisely when you need it most. For more on this, see The 5-Year Roth Conversion Window.

📋 Want to See How Sequence Risk Affects Your Plan?

I run sequence-of-returns stress tests for clients every week. We model what happens if the market drops 30% in year one, year five, or year ten of your retirement — and we show you what a guaranteed income floor would change. No cost. No obligation.

THE BIGGER PICTURE

Sequence Risk Is Not the Only Risk

It is just one of the retirement risks worth discussing. Here is the full picture.

📉 Market Risk

The risk that a market downturn permanently impairs your portfolio. Sequence risk is a subset of this — but it is the most dangerous version because it interacts with your withdrawals.

💸 Inflation Risk

The risk that rising prices erode your purchasing power over 20 or 30 years. Inflation is the number one concern for consumers — and for good reason. Over 25 years, 3% inflation cuts the value of a dollar nearly in half.

⏳ Longevity Risk

The risk that you live longer than your money. A 65-year-old today has a meaningful chance of living to 90 or beyond. Every additional year extends the period your portfolio must sustain withdrawals.

🏥 Health Care Risk

The risk that medical costs — including long-term care — consume your retirement savings. Medicare does not cover long-term care. Medicaid requires poverty to qualify. This is the single largest uninsured risk facing retirees today.

🏛️ Public Policy Risk

The risk that tax laws, Social Security rules, or Medicare provisions change in ways that affect your retirement income. WEP, GPO, and IRMAA are all examples of public policy risk in action.

🧠 Behavioral Risk

The risk that you make emotional decisions during a downturn — selling at the bottom, abandoning your plan, or claiming Social Security too early. Study after study shows that real investors do not behave like spreadsheets.

The point: Sequence-of-returns risk is one of several risks that can derail a retirement plan. The best retirement plans address all of them — not just one.

ABOUT YOUR ADVISOR

Dan Walsh — Retirement Income and Sequence-Risk Specialist

Born and raised in Maryland, Dan has been helping families design retirement income plans for over two decades.

Dan Walsh - NPN 3028543

Dan Walsh | NPN 3028543 | Licensed Insurance Agent

I was born at Holy Cross Hospital in Silver Spring, MD. I attended Saint Andrews the Apostle School, St. John the Evangelist School, Our Lady of Good Counsel High School, and graduated from the Smith School of Business at the University of Maryland.

I have been helping clients with annuities, life insurance, and retirement income planning for over two decades. I am licensed in Maryland, Virginia, Florida, and other states.

I answer my own phone. No call centers. No junior agents.

📞 (301) 569-2224 | ✉️ dwalsh@mdlifeins.com | NPN 3028543

Dan Walsh | Licensed Agent | Retirement Income and Sequence-Risk Specialist

NPN: 3028543 | MD Life Insurance | Google Verified

📋 Retirement Income Specialist
🏠 Born at Holy Cross, Silver Spring
🎓 Good Counsel → UMD Smith School
📞 (301) 569-2224
✉️ dwalsh@mdlifeins.com
🇺🇸 Licensed in MD, VA, FL, and other states

Helping families design retirement income plans that survive bad sequences. Licensed in Maryland, Virginia, Florida, and other states.

CTAs: Request Income Review → | Take Retirement Quiz →

🎙️ Listen to The Annuity & Retirement Podcast

Join Dan Walsh as he breaks down sequence-of-returns risk, retirement income, and the strategies that protect your savings. New episodes weekly.

🎧 Listen Now →

LEARN MORE

Related Guides from MD Life Insurance

If this post was useful, these guides go deeper on the retirement risks that matter most.

❓ ANSWERS FROM DAN

Frequently Asked Questions

What is sequence-of-returns risk? ▼
Sequence-of-returns risk is the risk that the order in which investment returns arrive — not just the average — permanently damages a retirement portfolio. Two retirees can have identical portfolios, identical withdrawals, and the same average return, but if one experiences negative returns early in retirement, the portfolio may never recover.
Why is sequence risk worse early in retirement? ▼
When you are withdrawing from a portfolio during a downturn, you are forced to sell assets at depressed prices. Those shares are permanently removed from the portfolio and cannot participate in the eventual recovery. A large withdrawal during a market decline can reduce the portfolio so much that future gains apply to a much smaller base.
What is the retirement red zone? ▼
The retirement red zone is the five years before and the five years after your retirement date. This is when sequence-of-returns risk is most dangerous, because a market downturn during this window can permanently impair the portfolio’s ability to fund a 30-year retirement.
How do I protect against sequence-of-returns risk? ▼
The most effective protection is to build a guaranteed income floor — through Social Security, pensions, or annuity income — that covers essential expenses. This means you are never forced to sell investments in a down market. Other strategies include cash buffers, delaying Social Security, Roth conversion planning, and the bucket strategy.
Is sequence risk only a concern for people who are already retired? ▼
No. It matters for anyone within five years of retirement — the “red zone.” If you are approaching retirement, the decisions you make now about asset allocation, guaranteed income, and withdrawal sequencing will determine whether a bad market in your first few years of retirement permanently damages your plan.
How do I request a personalized sequence-risk stress test? ▼
I run sequence-of-returns stress tests for clients every week. We model what happens if the market drops 30% in year one, year five, or year ten of your retirement — and we show you what a guaranteed income floor would change. Call me at (301) 569-2224 or visit mdlifeins.com/ae to request your review. Free. No obligation.

📋 Do You Know How Your Plan Survives a Bad Sequence?

I will run a personalized sequence-of-returns stress test for your retirement plan at no cost. No pressure. No obligation. Just clarity about the risk that matters most.

Licensed in MD, VA, FL, and other states | NPN 3028543


Schedule A Call