mdlifeins.com
Your 10 Best Objections to an Annuity — and Why I Still Think It's the Right Fit

Home  ›  Blog

Your 10 Best Objections to an Annuity — and Why I Still Think It’s the Right Fit

By Dan Walsh · Independent Insurance Broker · NPN 3028543 · Certified Long-Term Care Specialist · Life Insurance & Annuities

mdlifeins.com

Have Dan Contact Me

Life insurance, long-term care, annuities or final expense. Independent broker, multiple carriers, no pressure.

Prefer a quick quiz? LTC · Annuity · Term life

Search

Popular Topics

About the Author

Dan Walsh - Licensed Insurance Agent
Daniel Walsh
NPN 3028543
Independent Broker

I'm Dan Walsh, an independent insurance broker in Brookeville, MD. I specialize in long-term care insurance, fixed indexed annuities, and retirement income planning for families in Maryland and beyond.

I use a "manufacturing approach" to break complex insurance products into clear, understandable components, so you can make confident decisions without pressure. I also have deep expertise in federal benefit planning (FERS/CSRS, WEP/GPO) and IRA/tax strategies.

Before insurance, I founded and ran businesses including Guardian Funding Inc. and Lightning Wear Apparel. I'm licensed in Maryland and multiple other states. Verify my current licenses on NIPR (NPN 3028543). Not sure about your state? Contact me and I'll confirm.

🏅 Fixed Index Annuities 🛡️ Long-Term Care 🎓 Certified Long-Term Care Specialist 📊 Retirement Income
About MD Life Insurance →
🎙️

Protect What You've Built

New episodes weekly — annuity strategy and retirement planning, straight talk only.

Listen Now →

Follow Us

Your 10 Best Objections to an Annuity — and Why I Still Think It's the Right Fit
Related: Hear Dan explain it on the podcast, The Truth About Annuities, or see how fixed and indexed annuities work.
📋 A LETTER TO ANNUITY SHOPPERS

Your 10 Best Objections to an Annuity — and Why I Still Think It’s the Right Fit for You

You’ve looked at the illustrations. You’ve asked the hard questions. You’re still deciding. This is my honest answer to every objection I’ve heard in 28 years.

I want to write something different today.

Normally when an advisor writes about annuities, they lead with the benefits. The guarantees. The tax deferral. The lifetime income. And that’s fine — those things are real. But that’s not how the conversation actually goes in the room, and I think we all know it.

The real conversation goes like this: you sit down, you look at the illustration, and you say some version of “Yeah, but…”

And the “yeah, buts” are almost always smart. They’re not irrational. They’re not uninformed. In most cases, they’re the exact objections I would raise if I were sitting on your side of the table.

So I want to do something I don’t see enough advisors do. I want to lay out the ten objections I hear most often — the real ones, in your words — and answer each one honestly. Not with a sales script. With the actual math, the actual trade-offs, and the actual reason I still believe this is the right fit for the right person.

If you’re someone who is thinking about it but hasn’t pulled the trigger, this is for you. And if you’ve already decided against it, I’d still ask you to read the section near the end, because I think you’ll recognize yourself in one of the three conversations I describe.

Let’s get into it.

FIRST THINGS FIRST

The Mindset Shift

Before I get to the objections, I have to be honest about something.

I am not going to sell you on growth.

If you want to compare a fixed index annuity to the S&P 500 over the last ten years, you will win that argument every single time. The S&P averaged somewhere around 13% over the last decade. A capped FIA strategy averaged closer to 5%. I’m not going to pretend otherwise, and I’m not going to insult you by trying.

Here’s what I’m actually selling: the elimination of a specific risk that has a calculable dollar cost.

That risk is called sequence-of-returns risk. It’s the risk that a bad market in the first few years of your retirement does permanent, irreversible damage to your plan — not because your investments were bad, but because you were forced to sell them at the worst possible moment to pay for groceries.

That’s the whole pitch. It’s not a growth pitch. It’s a floor pitch. And if you’ll let me, I’ll show you why the floor matters more than the ceiling.

THE REAL CONVERSATION

The 10 Objections — and My Honest Answers

These are the objections I hear most from people who have already visited my site, looked at the illustrations, and are trying to decide whether this is right for them.

1“I’ll just put my $1 million in dividend stocks and call it a day.”

This is the big one. If this is your plan, I want you to read this part twice.

You might be right. A diversified portfolio of dividend-paying stocks is a legitimate retirement strategy. It has worked for a lot of people. I’m not going to tell you it won’t work for you.

But let me ask you one question:

What happens to that plan if the market drops 35% in year two of your retirement?

You’re 70. You’re pulling $60,000 or $70,000 a year to live on. In a down market, you’re not just watching your portfolio value fall — you’re selling shares at the bottom to fund your lifestyle. That’s the double hit. You lock in losses, you reduce the shares that would have recovered, and you permanently impair the portfolio’s ability to recover.

That’s sequence-of-returns risk. And it’s the single biggest killer of retirement plans that looked fine on paper.

Here’s the math that changes the conversation:

Let’s say you put $700,000 into dividend stocks for growth and legacy. And you put $300,000 into a fixed annuity that guarantees you $30,000–$35,000 a year for life, starting now.

What did that $300,000 actually buy you?

It bought you the ability to never sell a single stock in a down market. It bought you the ability to ride out 2008, 2020, and 2022 without touching your principal. It bought you the freedom to leave that $700,000 alone for 20 years and let it compound.

The annuity isn’t competing with your dividend stocks. It’s the reason your dividend stocks get to work.

That’s the reframe. You’re not choosing between the annuity and the portfolio. You’re using the annuity to make the portfolio survivable.

The line I use: “The annuity isn’t your investment. It’s your seatbelt. You still drive the car.”
2“The market beat your caps over the last 10 years.”

You’re right.

Over the last ten years, the S&P 500 averaged roughly 13% annualized. A 6.25% cap strategy averaged closer to 5%. I’m not going to argue with the math.

But here’s what that ten-year comparison hides:

  • 2022: S&P down 19%. Your FIA credited zero. Not negative. Zero.
  • 2020: S&P dropped 34% in a month. Your FIA credited zero.
  • 2018: S&P down 6%. Your FIA credited zero.
  • 2015: Flat to slightly negative. Your FIA credited zero.

In every down year, the FIA floor did its job. And here’s the part that doesn’t show up in a growth comparison:

You can’t retire on a paper balance. You retire on cash flow.

If you took $200,000 and rode the S&P from 2016 to 2026, you’d have somewhere around $600,000–$700,000 on paper — assuming you never touched it, never panicked, and never sold. That’s a real number, and it’s a good number.

But here’s what it doesn’t show: the income. That balance doesn’t guarantee you a paycheck at 85, at 95, at 105. It doesn’t protect you from a bad sequence of returns in your first five years of retirement. It doesn’t tell you what happens if you’re forced to sell at the bottom.

The FIA isn’t a growth product. It’s an income floor product. And the right comparison isn’t “S&P vs. cap.” It’s “guaranteed lifetime income vs. whatever the market happens to do.”

Show me the dividend portfolio that guarantees a paycheck at 95. That’s the comparison.

3“Surrender charges lock me up.”

This is the most misunderstood part of the contract, so let me clear it up.

Yes, there are surrender charges in the early years. Here’s what they actually are: the carrier’s way of recouping the 15% bonus they just credited to your account and the commission they paid me — which, by the way, you didn’t pay out of pocket.

Now here’s what nobody tells you:

One: You always have a free withdrawal. Most of these contracts let you take 10% per year, free and clear, no charge.

Two: The surrender charge applies to the bonus and the gain — not your original principal. Your Minimum Guaranteed Surrender Value (MGSV) is 87.5% of your premium, growing at 2.4%. That’s your floor. You cannot lose more than that.

Three: It’s a 10-year schedule that declines to zero. In year 11, you have 100% access, no charge, no MVA.

Four — and this is the real point: If you’re buying this to solve a 30-year retirement income problem, why are we talking about year three? The surrender charge isn’t a lock. It’s a commitment device that keeps you from making a panic decision in year two that wrecks the whole plan.

The line I use: “The lock-up isn’t the problem. It’s the reason the carrier can afford to guarantee you income for 40 years.”
4“The capped one didn’t grow enough, and the uncapped one has fees.”

This is the sophisticated objection — and honestly, it’s my favorite one, because it means you’re actually engaging with the product instead of dismissing it.

You’ve identified the exact trade-off. Here’s the truth: there is no free lunch. Every FIA is a trade-off between three levers:

  • Cap — the ceiling on what you earn
  • Participation rate — what percentage of the index you get
  • Fee — whether the rider has a charge

The no-fee, capped version gives you a lower ceiling but zero cost drag. The fee version gives you a higher participation rate — say, 60% instead of 40% — but charges 1.5% a year.

And here’s the number that actually matters, from the illustrations we ran:

Strategy 10-Year Annualized Return
S&P 500 with 6.25% cap (no fee) 4.97%
BlackRock with 60% participation, 1.5% fee 6.32%
BlackRock with 40% participation, no fee 5.25%

The fee version actually won over that period — 6.32% vs. 4.97%. The fee wasn’t the enemy. The participation rate was.

That’s why I run both illustrations. Not because I’m hiding something — because the right answer depends on which index performs better and what your priority is. If you want maximum upside, we take the fee version. If you want zero cost drag, we take the cap version.

There’s no wrong answer. There’s only the answer that fits you.

5“I don’t want to tie up my money for 10 years.”

Fair. Let me reframe what “tied up” actually means.

Year 1: You have a 10% free withdrawal. You can take $20,000 out of a $200,000 contract with no charge.

Year 2: Same 10% free withdrawal. Plus, if you need more, the surrender charge is declining.

Year 5: You’ve had five years of free withdrawals — potentially $100,000 of liquidity — plus the contract value has had five years to grow.

Year 10: Surrender charges are gone. Full liquidity.

Year 11+: You have a fully liquid, tax-deferred, guaranteed-income vehicle.

The “lock-up” narrative assumes you need 100% of your money on day one. If you did, you wouldn’t be buying an annuity — you’d be buying a CD. The annuity is for the money you don’t need on day one but want guaranteed on day 1,000.

6“What if the insurance company goes bankrupt?”

This is a real concern, and I’m glad you raised it.

First: Annuities are not bank deposits. They are not FDIC-insured. That’s true.

Third: The carriers I work with are A-rated or better by AM Best, S&P, and Moody’s. These are companies that have survived every major market event since the Great Depression. They are not fly-by-night operations.

Fourth — and this is the honest part: If you’re worried about carrier risk, we can split your premium across two or three carriers. That’s a real strategy, and I’ll do it if it helps you sleep at night.

No product is risk-free. But carrier risk is one of the most manageable risks in this conversation.

7“I don’t need income yet — I’m still working.”

Then we don’t turn on income yet.

A fixed index annuity isn’t just an income product. It’s a tax-deferred accumulation vehicle with a floor. You can let it grow for 10, 15, or 20 years before you take a single dollar of income. You get:

  • Tax deferral on all growth
  • A 0% floor in down years
  • A 15% bonus on day one
  • A death benefit for your heirs

And when you’re ready to turn on income, you can. The income rider is optional. The accumulation is the core.

If you’re still working, you’re in the accumulation phase. That’s a feature, not a bug.

8“What if I die before I use it?”

Then your beneficiaries get the greater of the contract value or the MGSV — and in many cases, the full accumulated value. The bonus is included. The growth is included.

This is not a “use it or lose it” product. It’s not a pension. It’s not Social Security. It’s a contract with a death benefit, and if you die early, your heirs don’t lose the money.

In fact, for many clients, the death benefit is a bigger number than what they put in. The 15% bonus doesn’t disappear if you die. It passes to your beneficiaries.

9“I can do better with real estate / crypto / my business.”

Maybe you can. But that’s not the comparison.

The annuity isn’t competing with your highest-return idea. It’s competing with the money you’re holding in cash, bonds, or CDs. The money you don’t want to lose. The money you need to be there when the market is down.

If you have a high-conviction investment that you believe will beat everything, go do it. But don’t do it with the money you can’t afford to lose. That’s what the annuity is for.

The annuity is not your growth engine. It’s your foundation. And you can be as aggressive as you want with everything above the foundation.

10“I don’t trust annuities / I’ve heard bad things.”

I get it. There are bad annuities out there. There are bad advisors out there. There are bad contracts with high fees, low caps, and surrender charges that never seem to end.

But that’s not an argument against annuities. That’s an argument against bad annuities.

The contract I’m showing you has:

  • A 15% premium bonus on day one
  • A 0% floor in down years
  • A 10% annual free withdrawal
  • A declining surrender charge that goes to zero in year 11
  • A guaranteed lifetime income option
  • A death benefit for your heirs

If you’ve been burned before, I understand. But don’t let a bad experience with a bad product close you off to a good product. Let me show you the difference.

The Core Reframe That Wins Them All

Here’s what I say when I’m losing the growth argument:

“I want to be really clear about something. I’m not trying to beat the market. If you want to beat the market, hire a money manager and go do it.

What I’m trying to do is make sure you never have to sell your investments at the worst possible time.

Every study on retirement income says the same thing: the biggest destroyer of wealth is not bad returns. It’s bad timing on withdrawals. A 30% drop in year one of retirement is catastrophic. A 30% drop in year 20 is a hiccup.

The annuity isn’t a replacement for your portfolio. It’s the layer underneath it that means you never have to touch the portfolio in a down year. It’s the floor. It’s the sleep-at-night money.

If you build a floor you can’t outlive, you can be as aggressive as you want with everything else. You can hold the dividend stocks. You can ride out the corrections. You can leave a bigger legacy.

The annuity isn’t the conservative choice. It’s the choice that lets you be more aggressive everywhere else.”
THREE CONVERSATIONS I STILL THINK ABOUT

Three Conversations I Still Think About

These aren’t complaints. They’re the three conversations that taught me the most. If you see yourself in one of them, I hope this is useful — and if you’ve already decided, I genuinely respect that.

📊 The $1 Million Dividend Stock Plan

He told me he was just going to put his $1 million into dividend-paying stocks and call it a day. He didn’t see the point of the annuity. He didn’t need the guarantee. He was confident in his plan — and honestly, I respect that confidence. It’s not blind. He’s thought about it.

The one thing I’d want him to have an answer to is this:

“If the market drops 35% in year two of your retirement, what’s your withdrawal plan?

If you have a solid answer, you don’t need me. If you don’t, that’s the whole conversation. Either way, I’m here.”

That’s not a pitch. It’s the one question that decides whether the plan is complete. If he has an answer, great — he’s done his homework. If he doesn’t, he knows where to find me.

📉 The Caps vs. Fees Trade-Off

He looked at the capped illustration and said the growth wasn’t enough. He looked at the uncapped illustration and said the fees were too high. He saw the trade-off clearly and decided neither version was right for him.

That’s a legitimate position. And the truth is, he’s not wrong about the trade-off — he’s just reading it differently than I do.

Here’s what I’d want him to know:

“You identified the exact trade-off, and I love that you see it. There is no free lunch. Every FIA is a trade-off between cap, participation rate, and fee.

The no-fee version has a lower ceiling. The fee version has a higher participation rate. The right answer depends on which index performs better and what your priority is.

I run both illustrations not because I’m hiding something — because the right answer depends on you. There’s no wrong answer. There’s only the answer that fits you.”

If he decides the trade-off isn’t worth it, that’s a real decision. I just want him to make it with the full picture in front of him.

🔒 The Surrender Charge Concern

He was worried about being locked up. He didn’t like the idea of not having full access to his money for 10 years. That’s a fair concern — and it’s one of the most common ones I hear.

Here’s what I’d want him to know:

“You have a 10% free withdrawal every year. You have a declining surrender charge that goes to zero in year 11. You have an MGSV that guarantees you can’t lose more than 12.5% of your premium, and that’s growing at 2.4%.

If you’re buying this to solve a 30-year retirement income problem, why are we talking about year three?

The surrender charge isn’t a lock. It’s a commitment device that keeps you from making a panic decision in year two that wrecks the whole plan.

The lock-up isn’t the problem. It’s the reason the carrier can afford to guarantee you income for 40 years.”

If the answer is still no, that’s fine. At least it’s a no with the real numbers in front of him.

A note to anyone I’ve quoted above: If you recognize yourself in one of these three, I want you to know I’m not writing this to relitigate anything. You made a decision, and I respect it. These are just the conversations that stuck with me — the ones that made me sharpen my own thinking. If you ever want to revisit it, I’m here. If not, that’s completely fine too.

THE BOTTOM LINE

The Bottom Line

I don’t lose these conversations because the product is weak. I lose them when I debate the wrong thing.

The annuity is not a growth product. It’s not competing with the S&P. It’s not competing with your dividend stocks. It’s not competing with your real estate.

It’s competing with the risk that a bad market in the first five years of your retirement permanently destroys your plan.

Stop debating returns. Start talking about the one risk that ends retirements.

And then let the returns take care of themselves.

📋 Want to Talk It Through?

If you’ve read this far, you’re probably one of the people I’m writing to. I’m not going to chase you. But if you want to have the conversation — the real one, not the sales pitch — I’m here.

Licensed in multiple states | NPN 3028543

ABOUT YOUR ADVISOR

Dan Walsh — Life Insurance and Retirement Income Specialist

Born and raised in Maryland, Dan has been helping families make coverage decisions.

Dan Walsh - NPN 3028543

Dan Walsh | NPN 3028543

I was born at Holy Cross Hospital in Silver Spring, MD. I attended Saint Andrews the Apostle School, St. John the Evangelist School, Our Lady of Good Counsel High School, and graduated from the Smith School of Business at the University of Maryland.

I have been helping clients with life insurance, annuities, and retirement planning for years — over 28 years. I am able to help in multiple states.

I answer my own phone. No call centers. No junior agents.

📞 (301) 569-2224 | ✉️ dwalsh@mdlifeins.com | Licensed in multiple states

Dan Walsh | Licensed Agent | Life Insurance and Retirement Income Specialist

NPN: 3028543 | MD Life Insurance | Google Verified

📋 Annuity & Retirement Income Specialist 🏠 Born at Holy Cross, Silver Spring 🎓 Good Counsel → UMD Smith School 📞 (301) 569-2224 ✉️ dwalsh@mdlifeins.com 🇺🇸 Licensed in multiple states

Helping families and federal employees make informed coverage decisions. Not affiliated with OPM. Licensed in multiple states.

CTAs: Request Coverage Review → | Take Retirement Quiz →

🎙️ Listen to The Annuity & Retirement Podcast

Join Dan Walsh as he breaks down life insurance, retirement income, and coverage decisions. New episodes weekly.

🎧 Listen Now →
❓ ANSWERS FROM DAN

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a fixed index annuity a good fit if I’m worried about market risk? ▼
A fixed index annuity is designed to eliminate sequence-of-returns risk. It provides a 0% floor in down years, so you never have to sell investments at the bottom to fund your lifestyle.
Do surrender charges lock up my money? ▼
Most contracts allow a 10% annual free withdrawal, and surrender charges decline to zero over 10 years. The MGSV guarantees you cannot lose more than 12.5% of your premium, and it grows at 2.4%.
What happens to my annuity if I die before I use it? ▼
Your beneficiaries receive the greater of the contract value or the MGSV, including the 15% bonus and any growth. It is not a use-it-or-lose-it product.
How do I request a personal projection? ▼
I can run your own numbers — your age, your premium, and what your income and legacy look like over the next 20 years. Call me at (301) 569-2224 or visit mdlifeins.com/term to request your review. Free. No obligation.

📋 Want to See Your Own Projection?

I will run your own numbers at no cost. No pressure. No obligation. Just a conversation about whether this fits your plan.

Licensed in multiple states | NPN 3028543

Schedule A Call